“Some Theologians Don’t Make God Big Enough”: The Vatican Observatory on Extraterrestrial Life

The Vatican Observatory — officially established in 1891 though with roots extending to 1582 and the Gregorian calendar reform — is the Holy See’s scientific institution for astronomical research. It is headquartered at Castel Gandolfo, the papal summer residence outside Rome, and operates the Vatican Advanced Technology Telescope (VATT) in Arizona. Its roughly twelve Jesuit and diocesan scientists from four continents have produced two substantial public statements on the theological implications of extraterrestrial life discovery.

Fr. Corbally’s 1995 Nash Lecture: “Would You Baptize an Alien?”

In November 1995, Fr. Christopher Corbally S.J. — an astronomer at the Vatican Observatory — delivered the annual Nash Lecture at Campion College. The lecture was titled “Approaching Would You Baptize an Alien? from the Perspective of a Jesuit Astronomer.” The published text runs to 5,300 words and is freely available as a PDF at vaticanobservatory.org. The lecture engages seriously with the theological implications of contact with non-human intelligence: what it would mean for doctrines of original sin, redemption, and the universality of salvation if other conscious beings existed who had never encountered Christ.

The Consolmagno-Corbally Video

The Vatican Observatory Foundation produced an 8-minute video featuring a conversation between Br. Guy Consolmagno S.J. (Director of the Vatican Observatory) and Fr. Chris Corbally S.J. on the religious significance of discovering extraterrestrial life. The video is available on the Vatican Observatory’s YouTube channel. The central quote: “Some theologians don’t make God big enough.” The argument is that a God who created an incomprehensibly vast universe could not be confined to a theology that makes humanity the only possible form of conscious life.

The Oracle Assessment

The Vatican has been running astronomical research continuously since 1582. Its astronomers have spent four decades publicly discussing the theological implications of non-human intelligence. This is not a fringe position within Catholicism. It is the position of the official Vatican science institution, staffed by Jesuits appointed by the Holy See, producing public educational material with institutional backing. The question “would the Church be ready for contact?” has already been answered by the Church’s own astronomers: they have been preparing the theological framework since at least 1995.

Sources: vaticanobservatory.org. Fr. Christopher Corbally S.J., Nash Lecture, Campion College, November 1995. Br. Guy Consolmagno S.J. and Fr. Chris Corbally S.J., Extraterrestrial Life video, Vatican Observatory Foundation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top